HDFC Bank: The White Elephant That Refuses to Dance

HDFC Bank is a fundamentally strong company. There is little argument about that. It is a respected franchise with a strong balance sheet, a huge deposit base and a long track record.

The business continues to grow. In FY26, deposits grew 14.4%, advances 12.1% and net profit 7.9%. Gross NPA stood at just 1.15%.

It is also one of India's most widely held institutional stocks, with DII holding around 41.75% and FII holding around 41.82%. It has high allocations across many mutual funds.

And yet, here is the irony: despite all this, the stock has failed to deliver meaningful returns to investors.

Over five years, the stock has delivered a negative return, with a CAGR of around -2%. Over the past year, it is down around 27%.

A great company. Strong profit growth. And yet, poor stock returns.

This is not unusual. Many companies go through such phases.

A good company does not necessarily make a good stock at every point in time. A good company can remain a frustrating stock for one year, three years, five years, or even longer.

The same applies to mutual funds. A good fund, managed by a competent fund manager and holding fundamentally strong companies, can still underperform its benchmark for years.

And this is where the real difficulty in investing begins.

When expected returns do not materialise, investors become uncomfortable. They compare. They look for what has performed best recently. They switch.

And then the cycle changes.

The fund they exited starts performing. The fund they bought starts underperforming. The investor feels unlucky. But often, there was nothing wrong with the original decision.

We expect good decisions to produce good results quickly.

But the market does not work according to our expectations.

You can make a sensible decision and still get a disappointing outcome. You can choose a great company or a good mutual fund and still have to wait. And no one really knows how long that wait will last.

That is the uncertainty of the stock market.

In any investment, an investor essentially has three choices: buy, hold, or sell. But every choice is a decision about an uncertain future.

We make decisions with limited information and incomplete data. Sometimes we are right. Sometimes we are wrong. And sometimes we are right, but the outcome takes longer than expected.

That distinction matters.

A bad outcome does not automatically mean a bad decision. A good outcome does not automatically mean a good decision.

An investor must learn to judge decisions by the quality of the reasoning behind them and not merely by the returns.

Patience is not simply the ability to wait. It is the discipline to stay with a well-reasoned decision when the expected outcome is not yet visible.

We can analyse. We can estimate. We can decide.

But we cannot control the timing of the outcome.

And that is what makes investing both frustrating and fascinating.

This is exactly what is happening with HDFC Bank.

Many investors are pleading, “Please dance… please dance… please!!!”

But the elephant is refusing to dance.

---

Pravinkumar Padalkar | ARN-179619 |

(Disclaimer: This blog is for educational purposes only. I do not hold HDFC Bank in my personal portfolio. We are not SEBI-registered investment advisers. Some of our clients may have exposure to HDFC Bank through their mutual fund holdings.)