.png)
Why India Arrives Late And What Must Change
- Wing Commander Pravinkumar Padalkar
- Feb 20
- 3 min read
The recent AI Summit in New Delhi created visible excitement.
Announcements.
Panel discussions.
Policy optimism.
Headlines about India’s AI potential.
The atmosphere was energetic. Confident. Forward-looking.
But as I listened, a harder truth emerged.
Why are we so often late?
Why do we just respond instead of lead?
When I look at global developments, the gap is difficult to ignore.
This isn’t criticism. It is introspection.
Historical Precedents.
Let us examine a few historical precedents.
1990s–Early 2000:- Taiwan, South Korea, United States
Semiconductor manufacturing and chip design ecosystems were consolidated, shaping global technology power for decades.
2001–2015:- China
Large-scale defence modernisation accelerated after WTO entry, positioning China as a major military power by the mid-2010s.
2005–2015 :- China
Rare earth mining and processing were strategically consolidated, securing dominance in critical minerals by 2010.
2012 :- United States
Deep learning breakthroughs transformed artificial intelligence from academic research into a commercial reality.
2015–2020 :- China
Lithium-ion battery manufacturing scaled aggressively, establishing global EV supply chain dominance.
In each case, by the time India moved decisively, other countries were already well ahead of the curve.
Executors Vs Innovators
India was never short of intelligent leaders.
Narayana Murthy and Nandan Nilekani built globally respected technology institutions. They understood software deeply. They anticipated the outsourcing wave early.
But while India perfected the services model, the United States was building platforms that defined the digital age.
Apple, under Steve Jobs, reinvented computing and transformed mobility with the iPhone in 2007.
Amazon, under Jeff Bezos,s launched AWS in 2006, laying the foundation of global cloud infrastructure.
Google shaped the AI revolution through sustained research investment.
Elon Musk pushed private space exploration and accelerated electric vehicles at scale.
While India executed global mandates, others built entirely new industries.
While India became the back office of the world, China built manufacturing dominance in electronics, batteries, and telecom infrastructure.
The contrast is subtle but decisive. India became excellent at execution. Others set the direction.
Why Are We Late?
This is not about talent. Ability is not the constraint. Systems are.
Some ecosystems reward experimentation. Others reward stability.
Some accept failure. Others stigmatise it.
Over time, that difference compounds.
Our education system emphasises rote learning, ranks, and predictable paths.
From childhood, the question is simple: who comes first?
Marks become identity. Performance replaces curiosity.
Children trained to reproduce answers grow into efficient executors.
But innovation needs something different: comfort with the unknown, patience, and the courage to try.
Breakthroughs come from experimentation, not from playing it safe.
Is India Changing?
Yes.
Digital public infrastructure like UPI is globally admired.
Startup ecosystems have deepened post-2015.
Semiconductor missions gained urgency post-2022 chip shortages.
EV adoption is accelerating.
Progress is visible.
But progress alone is not enough. We need more innovators. More risk-takers. More original thinkers, not just skilled executors.
The Real Question
The AI Summit created optimism. Optimism is important. But euphoria is not a strategy.
The real question for business leaders is simple:
Are we willing to risk capital to build what does not yet exist?
Innovation is uncomfortable. It demands patience. It demands tolerance for failure. It demands conviction before proof.
Unless we change how we think about failure, imagination, and long-term risk, we will continue to enter technological revolutions after they have matured rather than shape them at the beginning.
The future will not belong to the most knowledgeable societies. It will belong to the most innovative ones.
Innovate — or follow. The choice is ours.
-- Pady
Comments